| Year |
Opponent / Result |
|
| 1970 |
Montclair State 7, Hampden-Sydney 6 |
Knute Rockne Bowl (Atlantic City, NJ) |
| 1981 |
Montclair State 13, Alfred 12 |
NCAA Division III Quarterfinals (Alfred, NY) |
|
Widener 23, Montclair State 12 |
NCAA Division III Semifinals (Chester, PA) |
| 1985 |
Montclair State 28, W. Connecticut 0 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 1st Round (Montclair, NJ) |
|
Ithaca 50, Montclair State 28 |
NCAA Division III Quarterfinals (Ithaca, NY) |
| 1986 |
Montclair State 23, Hofstra 21 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 1st Round (Hempstead, NY) |
|
Ithaca 29, Montclair State 15 |
NCAA Division III Quarterfinals (Ithaca, NY) |
| 1989 |
Montclair State 23, Hofstra 6 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 1st Round (Montclair, NJ) |
|
Union College 45, Montclair State 6 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs Quarterfinals (Schenectady, NY) |
| 1993 |
Montclair State 17, Dickinson 9 |
ECAC Southwest Bowl |
| 1998 |
Montclair State 15, Widener 7 |
ECAC Southeast Bowl |
| 1999 |
Montclair State 37, Buffalo State 34 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 1st Round (Montclair, NJ) |
|
Montclair State 32, W. Connecticut 24 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 2nd Round (Danbury, CT) |
|
Rowan 42, Montclair State 14 |
NCAA DIvision III Quarterfinals (Montclair, NJ) |
| 2000 |
Springfield 31, Montclair State 29 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 1st Round (Springfield, MA) |
| 2001 |
Ithaca 35, Montclair State 23 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 1st Round (Montclair, NJ) |
| 2003 |
Montclair State 20, Allegheny 19 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 1st Round (Montclair, NJ) |
|
Ithaca 33, Montclair State 13 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 2nd Round (Montclair, NJ0 |
| 2005 |
Widener 27, Montclair State 18 |
ECAC Southeast Bowl |
| 2007 |
Montclair State 17, Albright 13 |
ECAC South Atlantic Bowl |
| 2008 |
Albright 42, Montclair State 14 |
ECAC South Central Bowl |
| 2009 |
Montclair State 38, Maine-Maritime 22 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 1st Round (Montclair, NJ) |
|
Mount Union 62, Montclair State 14 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 2nd Round (Alliance, OH) |
| 2010 |
Montclair State 16, Hampden-Sydney 14 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 1st Round (Hampden Sydney, VA) |
|
Wesley 44, Montclair State 7 |
NCAA Division III Playoffs 2nd Round (Dover, DE) |
